Wasn't aware there was a clutch on a D22 alternator? Thought they were just a solid rotor shaft going through a bearing with a pulley on the end?
It's possible but seems unlikely that both alternators are faulty (but who knows?).
Which model D22 do you have?
Afaik (on the zd30 models at least) the dash light circuit goes to ground through the rotor winding which initially "excites" the magnets. Then the output of the alternator takes over and you get the same voltage on both sides of the dash light (which then goes out). In other words it doesn't do anything after that. So if the alt light is on but then goes out when you start the engine, it seems to indicate at least that part is working ok. Which would make it seem more likely to be a problem with the regulator?
Not sure on other models that use led's and resistors though.
When you say you have 12V at idle, that seems like the alternator has no output at all. What do you get from the alternator itself (from the main terminal) to -ve? What happens when you give it a few revs, does the voltage change?
A wrong size pulley would make a difference re the internal frequency to the diodes, not sure what that would mean for the voltage though. What is the diameter of the one you are using?